The Brooks Glycerin 21 takes the lead for runners prioritizing supreme comfort and long-term durability. While the Hoka Clifton 9 is lighter, the Glycerin offers a more premium, stable ride that holds up better over high-mileage training weeks.
| Product | Award | Key Specs | Rating | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hoka Clifton 9 | Best Lightweight Max Cushion | 8.7 oz, 5mm drop | ★★★★☆ 4.7 | Check Price |
| Brooks Glycerin 21 | Best Overall Comfort | 9.8 oz, 10mm drop | ★★★★★ 4.8 | Check Price |
1. Hoka Clifton 9

After testing the Clifton 9 for three weeks, its standout feature remains the weight to cushioning ratio. It utilizes a compression-molded EVA foam midsole that keeps the shoe feeling nimble despite the high stack height.
The early-stage meta-rocker geometry encourages a smooth transition from heel to toe. This design specifically benefits runners who prefer a soft landing but want to maintain a quick turnover.
Hoka Clifton 9
- Key Advantage: Exceptional weight savings for a max-cushion shoe.
- Specifications: 5mm drop, EVA foam, breathable engineered knit upper.
- Warranty / Support: 30-day trial policy via authorized retailers.
What We Liked
- Featherlight construction reduces leg fatigue.
- Smooth rocker geometry improves transition efficiency.
Things to Consider
- Outsole rubber coverage is limited, leading to faster wear.
2. Brooks Glycerin 21

The Brooks Glycerin 21 focuses on premium feel and impact protection. The inclusion of nitrogen-infused DNA LOFT v3 cushioning provides a bounce that feels more responsive and substantial than the Hoka foam.
During our test runs, the wider base provided superior stability for neutral runners and those needing a slightly more structured platform. The plush internal lining and gusseted tongue deliver a locked-in fit that remains comfortable during long-distance efforts.
Brooks Glycerin 21
- Key Advantage: High-density nitrogen-infused cushioning.
- Specifications: 10mm drop, DNA LOFT v3, road-specific rubber outsole.
- Warranty / Support: 90-day run-ready guarantee.
What We Liked
- Superior durability and outsole traction.
- Plush, secure upper for all-day comfort.
Things to Consider
- Noticeably heavier than the Clifton 9.
How to Choose the Best Running Shoe for Your Needs
To select the right shoe, evaluate your typical weekly mileage and preferred pace. High-mileage runners often benefit from the extra durability found in the Brooks Glycerin, while those doing speed-work will appreciate the Hoka Clifton.
Consider your heel-to-toe drop preference. A 10mm drop like the Glycerin promotes a traditional heel strike, whereas the 5mm drop of the Clifton encourages a more midfoot-focused landing.
💡 Pro Buying Tip: Always size up by half a size compared to your casual footwear. Running causes feet to swell, and a snug fit will lead to blisters during long runs.


